RECALL: Smith’s 2% Milk & Buehler’s 2% Milk – various sizes

Smith’s 2% milk & Buehler’s 2% milk – various sizes

  • Date of recall: 9/2/15
  • UPC code(s): see table below
  • Lot code(s) (if applicable): see table below
  • Manufacturer of item: Dairy Enterprises, Inc.
  • Toll free number of manufacturer for information & questions: 330-683-8710
  • Reason for recall: could have traces of chocolate residue in them
  • PLEASE return products to any Buehler’s location for a refund or replacement


Buehler’s and Smith’s Milk Recall Smith Dairy Recall table

Posted on by Karen Brenner in Blog, News/Media, Recall

22 Responses to RECALL: Smith’s 2% Milk & Buehler’s 2% Milk – various sizes

  1. Judy Robinson says:

    Is the Code Date the same as the Sell By Date????

  2. Mickey swartz says:

    WOW !! This is great that you value me as a customer that a recall is sent to me. Great use of technology!! Thank you!……..Mickey

  3. Jackie Harris says:

    For the milk recall, it was stated on your email that UPC codes would be listed but they are not. My milk is stamped 9/16; is it safe? My UPC code is: 70424 00032.

    • Karen Brenner says:

      Hi Jackie,

      Here are the UPCs:

      Smith Gallon – 70424-00035
      Smith ½ gal – 70424-00021
      Smith qrt – 70424-00023
      Smith pint – 70424-00141
      Smith ½ pint – 70424-00188

      Buehler Gallon – 70424-00032
      Buehler ½ gal – 70424-00606

    • Karen Brenner says:


      Your milk’s UPC is on the list below, but the code date – 9/16 – is not included in the recall. So yours is fine! :-)

  4. Ruby Suttoon says:

    I do not see a UPC Code listed above. The See By Date on my bottle, which is a 1/2 gallon, is Sept. 15, so I am assuming it I not involved.

  5. Geraldine Robinson says:

    Is this a health risk for someone who is not allergic to chocolate?

  6. Teresa Minarchick says:

    Checked my milk and it is dated Sep 15, so I am good.

    Just wanted to say how much I appreciate your email and concern for your customers.
    Keep up the good work!

  7. Adriana Dryer says:

    Thank you. I will check the information.

  8. Kathleen Frys says:

    I have a 1/2 gall of 2% milk with 39-111 code but date is 9/11. Is that ok to use?

  9. william Hootman says:

    Thank you for the notice,I have been drinking this milk and have not had any problems

  10. Patricia Gross says:

    My sell by date is September 4. Is my bottle in the recall? If so do I bring the milk back to Buehler’s? I already drank some of it.

    • Karen Brenner says:

      Hi Patricia,
      Your milk is not included in the recall. The Sell by Dates in the recall are September 17, 18 and 19.

  11. Patricia M. Gray says:

    Thanks for the notice……my milk is in the recall…..taste great….no chocolate issues…so I will just drink it!

  12. Mary Mrang says:

    THANK YOU for the alert!!!!!!!!
    My milk is not on the recall
    but it is GREAT to know your
    company is concerned about
    your customers.
    Again THANK YOU.

  13. Ashley says:

    Would this of made my baby sick?

    • Karen Brenner says:

      The recall is because there were traces of chocolate residue in with the white milk. If your baby has a severe allergy to chocolate, it is possible, but if not, there is nothing about the milk that would make anyone sick.

  14. Randy Burrier says:

    Thank you so much for this alert. My milk is on the recall list, but since I am not allergic to chocolate – I will not be returning it.

    Definitely do appreciate that you sent an email to let me know about things, though!

    Thank you again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>