Order Catering Online!

Love the convenience of online ordering? You can now order catering online and it will be ready in 48 hours!

Amy Kaylor

Amy Kaylor

Director of Catering

We’re here to help!

It’s so easy to plan an event when you have our Catering Specialists on your side! From choosing the perfect food, customizing our services to your needs and coordinating all the details, our goal is to make your life easy and your event outstanding!

What We Do Best

  • Wedding Receptions
  • Anniversaries
  • Baby & Bridal Showers
  • Birthday Parties
  • Corporate & Office Events
  • Funeral & Memorial Events
  • Graduations
  • Holiday Celebrations
  • Organizational Lunches & Events
  • Family Picnics

Ordering Information

How to Order

To place your Catering Order – call or stop by your nearest Buehler’s location.

Or place your order online!

Custom Orders

Don’t see what you’re looking for?  Our team of Chefs and Catering Specialists are here to help.  We can create custom menus and service options for any size group.  Give us a call today!

Notice

We appreciate at least a 48-hour notice on catering orders; however, we pride ourselves in our ability to accommodate last minute requests.  Give us a call to discuss what menu items can be made available in a pinch.

Pick Up

When coming to our store to pick up your order, please proceed to the Service Center where a smiling face will greet you.  We will bring your order right to you!

Delivery

Whether you are 5, 10, 15 or more miles from our store, we will deliver and set up your food and beverages so you can save time! Local $15, Out of Town $25, and Long Distance $35.

Staff

We can provide staffing to make any occasion especially easy.  For $20 per staffer, per hour, service can include set up and tear down, buffet or plated meal service, bussing, non-alcoholic beverage service and much more.  Let us do the work so you don’t have to!

Hot or Cold

Your food can be prepared hot and ready to serve; or we can cook, then cool so it is ready to reheat at your convenience.

Pricing

Prices are subject to change.

  • Attention persons with food allergies to wheat, soy, eggs, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, fish and shellfish: Although the staff at Buehler’s takes precautions to safely handle and label ingredients and foods that contain potential allergens, cross-contamination may occur.  Highly sensitive individuals should discuss the risks of cross-contamination with their physician.

(V) = Vegetarian (additonal vegetarian items available upon request)

Breakfast

Small serves 8 -12 • Medium serves 15 – 20 • Large serves 25 – 30 • Half serves 12 • Full serves 24

Pastries & Fruit

  • Donuts
    From glazed to cake and apple fritters to cream sticks we make them fresh daily just for you. (Small: $24, Medium: $48, Large: $72)
  • Breakfast Pastries
    Gourmet muffins, bagels and/or croissants. (Small: $24, Medium: $48, Large: $72)
  • Fresh Fruit Salad
    A seasonal assortment of our ripest and sweetest melons, berries, pineapple and grapes. (Small: $18, Medium: $30, Large: $48)

Hot Breakfast

  • Breakfast Casserole (V)
    Hearty made-from-scratch hash brown casserole available in classic sausage, California, western or sundried tomato feta. (Half: $30, Full: $58)
  • French Toast (V)
    Traditional thick-cut French toast with butter and maple syrup on the side. (Half: $35, Full: $68)
  • Biscuits & Gravy
    Warm, flaky biscuits with our creamy sausage gravy. (Half: $40, Full: $75)
  • Scrambled Eggs (V)
    Garnished with cheddar cheese. (Half: $18, Full: $35)

    No cholesterol eggs: (Half: $24, Full: $44)

  • Hash Brown Potatoes (V)
    Crispy, shredded breakfast potatoes. (Half: $25, Full: $45)
  • Sausage Links
    Juicy pork or turkey sausage links. (Half: $40, Full: $75)
  • Bacon
    Crispy applewood smoked bacon or lean turkey bacon. (Half: $40, Full: $75)

Breakfast Buffet

Pricing is per person. Minimum 20 people.

  • Classic Breakfast Buffet
    $12
    Fluffy scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, hash browns, fresh fruit and our house-made bagels with cream cheese.
  • French Toast Buffet
    $12
    Our famous French toast with maple syrup and butter deliciously paired with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon and fresh fruit.
  • Breakfast Casserole Buffet
    $12
    Made-from-scratch egg, hashbrown casserole, fresh fruit and gourmet muffins.

    Choose from:

    • Classic Sausage
    • California
    • Sundried Tomato Feta
    • Western 

Fruit & Yogurt Parfaits

Fresh fruit, creamy yogurt and crunchy granola. A Buehler’s signature item!
Individual 10 oz. cup, $4 each
Build your own station, $4 per person

Complete your morning with our freshly brewed Scenic River coffee and a gallon of Smith’s orange juice.

BoxLunches

  • Express
    $10
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, chips and gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Classic
    $12
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, chef prepared side and a gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Executive
    $14
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, chef prepared side, chips, bottled water and a chocolate chunk gourmet cookie.
  • Garden
    $12
    Your choice of freshly prepared garden salad, pita bread and a gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Junior
    $8
    Your choice of sandwich on fresh bread, served with chips and a gourmet chocolate chunk cookie. Choose from ham & American, peanut butter & jelly or turkey & co-jack.
  • Feeding a Group?

    We can make your box into a bufffet!
    Same price = easy & delicious

SANDWICH & WRAP CHOICES
  • Chicken Salad Croissant
  • Turkey Club Sub
  • Italian Sub
  • Turkey Club Wrap
  • Vegetarian Wrap
SALADS
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar
  • Strawberry Salad with Grilled Chicken
  • Chef Salad
SIDES
  • Potato Salad
  • Cole Slaw
  • Fresh Fruit Salad
  • Macaroni Salad

Party Trays

Small (serves 8-12) • Medium (serves 15-20) • Large (serves 25-30)

Buehler's Fresh Foods sandwiches
  • Market Deli Meat Platter
    CAB roast beef, mild smokehouse ham, Buehler’s premium turkey breast, hard salami and sliced Italian bread.  (Small: 48, Medium: $80, Large: $120)
  • Market Deli Combination Platter
    Mild smokehouse ham, Certified Angus Beef roast beef and Buehler’s premium turkey breast team up with colby, muenster and Swiss cheeses. (Small: 48, Medium: $80, Large: $120)
  • Boar’s Head Meat Platter
    Ovengold roasted turkey breast, smoked black forest ham, seasoned filet of roast beef and hard salami. (Small: $60, Medium: $100, Large: $150)
  • Boar’s Head Combination Platter
    Ovengold roasted turkey breast, smoked black forest ham, seasoned filet of roast beef, longhorn Colby, muenster and Switzerland Swiss cheese. (Small: 60, Medium: $100, Large: $150)
  • Deluxe Sandwich Topper Tray (V)
    Lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, banana peppers, mustard, mayo and ketchup.  (Small: $20, Medium: $30, Large: $50)
  • Slider Sandwich Tray
    Choose up to 3: Oven Roasted Turkey, Mild Smokehouse Ham, Roast Beef, or Chicken, Tuna, Ham or Egg Salad (Small: $30, Medium: $60, Large: $90)
  • Petite Croissant Sandwich Tray
    Choose up to 3: Oven Roasted Turkey, Mild Smokehouse Ham, Roast Beef, or Chicken, Tuna, Ham or Egg Salad. (Small: $35, Medium: $65, Large: $95)
  • Wrap Sandwich Tray
    Turkey club and Roast Beef Dijon cut in half and arranged on a tray. (Small: $55, Medium: $95, Large: $135)
  • Sub Sandwich Tray
    A combination of our favorite Hoagies (Italian and Turkey Club) cut and ready to eat. (Small: $55, Medium: $95, Large: $135)
  • Meat & Cheese Snacker
    Hard salami, trail bologna, pepperoni, colby, provolone, and Swiss cheese, garnished with grapes. (Small: $40, Medium: $60, Large: $80)
  • Cheese Snacker (V)
    An assortment of cut cheeses garnished with grapes. (Small: $30, Medium: $50, Large: $70)
  • Trail Bologna & Swiss
    An Ohio favorite! Troyer’s trail bologna and Holmes County Swiss cheese. Garnished with grapes. (Small: $30, Medium: $50, Large: $70)
  • Cheese Ball Tray (V)
    Cracker cut cheese around our sharp cheddar cheese ball. (Medium $30)
Buehler's Fresh Foods party trays

CIRCLE SUBS

  • Circle Sub Classic
    $52
    Buehler’s premium turkey breast, mild smokehouse ham and Colby cheese, garnished with lettuce, tomato and pickle on a soft, Italian style bun with our famous sub sauce on the side. (Entree – serves 8-12, Appetizer serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Italian
    $52
    Mild smokehouse ham, hard salami, pepperoni, provolone, tomato, lettuce, banana peppers and Italian dressing on a soft, Italian style bun. (Entree – serves 8-12, Appetizer serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Deluxe
    $60
    Buehler’s premium turkey breast and CAB roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickle on an Italian style bun. Our famous sub sauce on the side. (Entree – serves 8-12, Appetizer serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Vegetable (V)
    $52
    Don’t forget about your veggie lovers! A soft Italian style bun piled high with spinach, red onion, black olives, carrots, bell peppers, tomato, pickles and creamy vegetable yogurt cheese. Served with a side of our famous dill dip.  (Entree – serves 8-12, Appetizer serves 15-20)
Buehler's Fresh Foods vegetable trays

FRUITS & VEGGIES

Small serves 8 – 12
Medium serves 15 – 20
Large serves 25 – 30

  • Traditional Vegetable Tray (V)
    An assortment of fresh broccoli and cauliflower florets, baby carrots and celery sticks with creamy dill dip.  (Small: 25, Medium: $45, Large: $75)
  • Seasonal Fruit Tray (V)
    A mouthwatering array of our freshest melons, pineapple, grapes and berries. (Small: $40, Medium: $60, Large: $90)
  • Deluxe Relish Tray (V)
    Baby carrots, celery sticks, broccoli and cauliflower florets, radishes, sweet pickle mix, tomatoes, cucumbers and olives are all arranged around Buehler’s fresh dill dip. (Small: $30, Medium: $50, Large: $80)

Starters

Medium (50 pcs), Large (100 pcs)

  • Cocktail Shrimp
    Succulent tail-on jumbo shrimp (16/20 ct.) served with our house-made cocktail sauce and fresh lemon wedges. (Medium: $80, Large: $110)
  • Bruschetta Platter (V)
    Build your own! Sliced Italian baguette, tomato basil bruschetta and shaved parmesan cheese granished with fresh basil. (Medium: $45, Large: $70)
  • Deviled Eggs (V)
    (Medium: $40, Large: $75)
  • Mini Pinwheels
    Deliciously colorful, bite-size tortilla rollups. Available in roast beef-cheddar, jalapeno-bacon and turkey-cranberry. (Medium: $50, Large: $95)
  • Potato Skins
    Crispy potato skins topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, scallions and a side of sour cream.  (Medium: $50, Large: $95)
  • Mini Crab Cakes

    Bite size crab cakes made from scratch and served with our roasted red pepper remoulade.  (Small: $60, Medium: $125, Large: $240)

  • Sauerkraut Balls
    Great for any party! Served with honey mustard dressing. (Medium: $30, Large: $55)
  • Cocktail Meatballs
    Juicy meatballs tossed in our BBQ or creamy mushroom sauce.  (Medium: $30, Large: $60)
  • Pretzel Bites (V)
    Baked pretzel bites with warm cheddar cheese sauce for dipping.  (Medium: $25, Large: $45)
Buehler's Fresh Foods catering

SALADS

Small: 8-12, Medium: 15-20, Large: 25-30

  • Caesar (V)
    Romaine lettuce topped with mushrooms, red onion, croutons and parmesan cheese. Served with a side of Caesar dressing. (Small: $18, Medium: $25, Large: $44) Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken (Small: $32, Medium: $44, Large: $74)
  • Garden Salad (V)
    Crisp lettuce, cherry tomatoes, red onion, and green peppers make this a refreshing salad.  (Small: $16, Medium: $23, Large: $39)

    Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
    Small $29, Medium $40, Large $68

  • Harvest Salad (V)
    Crisp gala apples, sugared pecans, and sweet craisins are served over mixed greens and topped with crumbled bleu cheese and raspberry dressing. (Small: $26, Medium: $38, Large: $58)
  • Strawberry Salad (V)
    Strawberries and crumbled bleu cheese on mixed greens, sugared pecans and raspberry dressing. (Small: $26, Medium: $38, Large: $58)

    Strawberry Salad with Grilled Chicken
    Small: $36, Medium: $52, Large: $82

Buehler's Fresh Foods Catering Potato Salad

CHEF PREPARED

Small: 8-12, Medium: 15-20, Large: 25-30

  • Potato Salad (V)
    Traditional potato salad just like grandma used to make. (Small: $15, Medium: $25, Large: $40)
  • Macaroni Salad (V)
    Elbow macaroni, carrots, pickle relish and fresh celery in our own creamy sauce. (Small: $15, Medium: $25, Large: $40)
  • Italian Garden Pasta (V)
    Classic Italian pasta salad with tomatoes and green peppers. Simple and delicious! (Small: $18, Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Broccoli Salad
    Broccoli, sweet raisins and crumbled bacon tossed in our signature creamy dressing. (Small: $21, Medium: $35, Large: $56)
  • Cole Slaw (V)
    A Buehler’s signature recipe. (Small: $15, Medium: $25, Large: $40)
  • Fresh Fruit Salad (V)
    A seasonal assortment of our ripest and sweetest melons, berries, pineapple and grapes. (Small: $18, Medium: $30, Large: $48)

SIDES

Half (serves 12), Full (serves 24)

  • Cheesy Potato Casserole
    Thinly shredded potatoes with sour cream and a blend of savory cheeses. Covered with a corn-flake topping and baked until golden brown. (Half: $36, Full $72)
  • Green Beans
    • Honey Glazed
    Fresh green beans blended with honey, dried cranberries, and sugared pecans. A great addition to any fall meal.

    • Garlic
    Green beans sauteed in a butter garlic sauce.

    • Casserole
    Green beans mixed with cream of mushroom soup and topped with fried onions and then baked until bubbly

    • Provencal
    Fresh green beans with a blend of garlic, tomatoes, basil and sage.

    (Half: $27, Full: $52)

Buehler's Catering Mashed Potatoes
  • Honey Glazed Carrots
    Delicate baby carrots roasted in a light honey sauce. (Half: $25, Full: $45)
  • Smoked Gouda Redskin Potatoes
    Boring potatoes move over! Sweet red potatoes, caramelized onions and creamy smoked gouda cheese make these a crowd pleaser. (Half: $36, Full: $72)
  • Homemade Mac & Cheese
    Tender shells mixed with a creamy blend of cheeses.  (Half: $36, Full: $72)
  • Twice Baked Potatoes
    A baked potato stuffed with potato, cheddar cheese, bacon, sour cream, and scallions.  (Half: $45, Full: $89)
  • Grilled Marinated Veggies
    Mixed vegetables marinated in our signature marinade and grilled over an open flame.  (Half: $36, Full: $72)
  • Mashed Potatoes
    (Half: $25, Full: $50)
  • Parsley Noodles
    Tender egg noodles mixed with spices and parsley.  (Half: $25, Full: $50)
  • Oven Roasted Rosemary Potatoes
    Yukon gold potatoes, olive oil and fresh rosemary make these a crowd pleaser! (Half: $27, Full: $52)
  • JOJOS (V)
    Jumbo potato wedges, breaded & deep fried. (Small – 24 pcs: $15, Large – 48 pcs: $25)

HOMEMADE SOUP

ASK ABOUT OUR SEASONAL SOUPS

ENTREES

Half (serves 12), Full (serves 24)

Buehler's catering salmon
  • Meat Lasagna
    Layers of lasagna noodles, hearty meat sauce and rich ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. (Half: $49, Full: $89)
  • Vegetable Lasagna (V)
    Layered noodles, fresh vegetables and cheeses in a rich cream sauce. (Half: $45, Full: $85)
  • Rotini with Red Sauce (V)
    Topped with a 3 cheese blend. (Half: $29, Full: $55)

    With Meatballs
    (Half: $35, Full: $70)

  • Penne Pasta Primavera (V)
    Fresh vegetables and creamy garlic alfredo sauce over penne pasta. (Half: $48, Full: $95)
  • Stuffed Shells (V)
    Ricotta stuffed shells topped with house made red sauce. (Half: $39, Full: $75)
  • Meatballs & Marinara
    Buehler’s hand formed meatballs stuffed with fresh mozzarella and topped with house made red sauce. (Half: $38, Full: $76) 
  • Oven Roasted Pork Tenderloin
    Succulent tenderloin and sautéed onions in an Asian inspired marinade. (Half: $45, Full: $89)
  • Oven Roasted Turkey Breast
    Juicy turkey breast seasoned and oven roasted to golden perfection. (Half: $45, Full: $96)
  • Stuffed Chicken Breasts
    A juicy Gerber chicken breast stuffed with our classic bread dressing and topped with gravy.  (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Chicken Parmesan
    A breaded chicken breast topped with our zesty marinara and melted provolone cheese.  (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Grilled Lemon Chicken
    A Gerber chicken breast marinated in fresh-squeezed lemon juice.  (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu
    A fresh chicken breast rolled with ham and Swiss cheese, smothered in dijon mustard and seasoned bread crumbs. (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Asiago Chicken
    A juicy chicken cutlet lightly breaded and pan fried. Encrusted with asiago cheese and melted until bubbly and golden. (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Italian Mushroom Chicken
    Marinated Gerber chicken seasoned with our own Italian seasoning blend and topped with creamy mushroom sauce. (Half: $60, Full: $120)
  • Pot Roast
    Tender beef slow roasted in a rich and hearty gravy.

    (Half: $75, Full: $140)

    Pot Roast with Harvest Veggies

    (Half: $99, Full: $189)

  • Swiss Steak
    A hearty steak tenderized and slow cooked in our own beef gravy.  (Half: $48, Full: $95)
  • Prime Rib
    Certified Angus Beef prime rib roast served with au jus.  (Market Price)
  • Glazed Ham
    Mild smokehouse ham sliced and baked with our homemade glaze and garnished with pineapple.  (Half: $49, Full: $89)
  • Grilled Salmon
    Lightly seasoned salmon filet grilled to perfection.  Market Price
  • Baked Cod
    A fresh cod filet rolled in a combination of corn flakes and cracker crumbs. Baked until golden brown and flaky. (Half: $65, Full: $130)
  • Fried Chicken
    Our authentic crispy fried chicken, great for your next party or family get together! (Small – 24 pc: $29, Medium – 48 pc: $56, Large – 96 pc: $99)
  • Chicken Tenders
    Freshly battered and deep fried golden brown with choice of dipping sauce. (Half: $39, Full: $75)
  • Beef Tips & Gravy
    Our homemade beef tips in a rich brown gravy. (Half: $45, Full: $90) 

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Buehler's catering salmon

DINNER BUFFET

Choose from the ENTREES and SIDES selections in this menu.
Plastic disposable table ware and chafing dishes included. (20 person minimum)

  • House
    $16
    1 entrée and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)
  • Signature
    $20
    2 entrées and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)
  • Grand
    $24
    3 entrées and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)

SMOKEHOUSE BBQ

Smokehouse BBQ Buffet

20 Person Minimum • Disposable Service Ware Included • Available Year Round at Select Locations

Buehler's Smokehouse BBQ ribs
  • BBQ Buffet Meat Selections
    • Pulled Pork
    • Chopped Brisket
    • Smoked Sausage
    • Pulled Chicken
    • Smoked Chicken Pieces
  • BBQ Buffet Side Selections
    • Smoked Mac & Cheese
    • Smokehouse Beans
    • Smoked Baked Potato
    • Coleslaw
    • Smoked Veggies
    • Potato Salad
    • Tossed Salad
  • The Little Squealer
    $12
    One meat, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce. (per person)
  • The Fine Swine
    $14
    Our most popular! Two meats, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce.  (per person)
  • Hog Heaven
    $16
    Three meats, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce. (per person)
  • Rib Buffet
    $18
    Ribs plus one meat option, 2 sides, buns, & BBQ sauce. (per person)

Smokehouse BBQ Entrees and Sides

Half serves 12 • Full serves 24

  • Smokehouse Pulled Pork or Chicken
    (Half: $45, Full: $89)
  • Smokehouse Beef Brisket
    CAB beef brisket, rubbed with our secret recipe of dry spices and smoked for hours. (Half: $99, Full: $198)
  • Smokehouse Ribs
    Dry rubbed St. Louis style ribs topped with BBQ sauce. (Market Price)
  • Smokehouse Sausage
    Locally made and smoked in-house.(Half: $45, Full: $85)
  • Smokehouse Mac and Cheese
    Our traditional creamy, homemade mac & cheese finished in smoker for a subtle hint of hickory. (Half: $39, Full: $75)
  • Smokehouse Beans (V)
    A blend of great northern & kidney beans simmered in our signature Smokehouse BBQ sauce. (Half: $25, Full: $50)
  • Smoked Veggies (V)
    A variety of our favorite fresh veggies tossed in dry spices and smoked over hickory wood. (Half: $36, Full: $72)
  • Smokehouse 8-Piece Chicken
    Fall-off-the-bone chicken pieces fresh from our hickory wood smoker. (Half: $39, Full: $75)

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

EXTRAS

DIPS & SPREADS

  • Buehler’s Dill Dip
    $5/lb
  • Fruit Yogurt Dip
    $7/lb
  • Buffalo Chicken Dip
    $7/lb
  • Spinach Dip
    $6/lb
  • Fresh Salsa
    $6/lb
  • Hummus
    $8/lb
  • Dipping Sauces
    $6/lb

BREADS & CHIPS

  • Sliced Italian Bread
    $4
    1 loaf
  • Garlic Bread
    $4
    1 loaf
  • Buehler’s Buns
    $3
    8 pack
  • Assorted Crackers
    $6
    12 oz. box
  • Pita Triangles
    $5
    24 piece box
  • Lays Potato Chips
    $5
    8 oz. bag
  • Tortilla Chips
    $5
    10 oz. box
  • Slider Buns
    $5
    1 dozen
  • Dinner Rolls
    $3
    6 pack

BAKERY SWEETS

Small (serves 8-12), Medium (serves 15-20), Large (serves 25-30)

TRAYS

  • Buehler’s Cookies
    Chocolate chip, peanut butter, white chocolate macadamia nut or oatmeal raisin.  (Small: $10, Medium: $18, Large: $25)
  • Our House Cookies
    Made from scratch dough, iced with our homemade buttercream icing and seasonally decorated. (Small: $10, Medium: $18, Large: $25)
  • Gourmet Cookies
    Freshly baked jumbo cookies that come in a wide variety of flavors including chunky chocolate chip, caramel pecan, or cranapple. (Small: $15, Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Buehler’s Brownies
    Buehler’s favorite frosted fudge brownie with or without nuts. (Small: $12, Medium: $22, Large: $32)
Buehler's bakery catering cookies and bars
  • Forbidden Brownies
    Rich and gooey layered brownies. Original and salted caramel. (Small: $30, Medium: $58, Large: $75)
  • Cupcakes
    Perfect for birthdays, holidays or any occasion. We bake our cupcakes fresh and frost with buttercream icing. Available in white and chocolate.  (Small: $18, Medium: $36, Large: $54)
  • Sweets Sampler
    A variety of cookies, brownies, clothespin cookies and delicious chocolate fudge. (Small: $15, Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Lemonberry Bars
    Refreshing lemon bars filled with blueberries and white chocolate shortbread crust. (Small: $25, Medium: $48, Large: $68)
  • Also available:  PIES, TORTES & MORE!  Ask about our seasonal selections!

SPECIALTY

Half (serves 12) • Full (serves 24)

  • Black Forest Dessert
    Oreo crust with a sweet cream filling topped with cherries and Jello. This is a Buehler’s staple! (Half: $35, Full: $65)
  • Tiramisu
    Coffee soaked lady fingers layered with light marscarpone cream topped with sweet cocoa. (Half: $54, Full: $108)
  • Fruit Crisp
    Baked apples or cherries with our scratch-made butter streusel topping. (Half: $25, Full: $48)

CUSTOM CAKES

Let us customize a delicious, one-of-a-kind homemade cake for your special occasion.

Choose from our premium homemade buttercream icings, rolled fondant and Marzipan enrobed cakes, to our fresh and seasonal fruit fillings and specialty cake flavors like European sponge. Let us help you create something unique!

FREE CONSULTATION

with one of our talented decorators!

We do it all!

  • BIRTHDAYS
  • ANNIVERSARIES
  • GRADUATIONS
  • BRIDAL & BABY SHOWERS
  • WEDDINGS
  • HOLIDAY/SEASONAL
  • AND MORE!

BEVERAGES

All beverages include cups. Ready to serve.

  • Scenic River Coffee
    $12
    Our favorite brand of coffee! Available in Regular or Decaf. Includes sugar, sugar substitutes, creamer, and stir sticks. (Per gallon)
  • Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
    $9
    Freshly brewed just for you!  Includes sugar and sugar substitutes.  (Per gallon)
  • Flavored Iced Tea
    $9
    Choose your favorite flavor. Includes sugar packets. (Per gallon)
  • Buehler’s Lemonade
    $7
    Our refreshing house brand lemonade. (Per gallon)
  • Smith’s Orange Juice
    $8
    Our favorite brand of refreshing orange juice. (Per gallon)
  • Smith’s Punch
    $6
    Choose from a variety of flavors. (Per gallon)
  • Case Water
    $15 per case
    24 pack Buehler’s brand water. Perfect for large groups.
  • Bottled Water
    $1 per bottle
    Buehler’s own 100% Natural Spring Water.
  • Canned Soda
    $1 per can
    Your choice of refreshing Coca Cola or Pepsi brand products.
  • 2 Liter Soda
    $4 per bottle
    Your choice of refreshing Coca Cola or Pepsi brand products.

PARTY SUPPLIES

  • Tableware
    Make clean-up a breeze with these durable options.

    • Cutlery Roll  50¢ ea.
      (heavy napkin, knife, fork & spoon)
    • Heavy Duty Ovation Paper Plates/Bowls $1 per person
    • Clear Plastic Plates/Bowls $2 per person
  • Serving Utensils
    Heavy duty, plastic disposable. $1 ea.

    • Tongs (6 or 10 inch)
    • Serving Spoon
    • Ladle (1 or 4 oz.)
    • Pie Server
    • Spatula
  • Keepers
    Don’t forget these convenient party savers.

    • Plastic Table Cover $3 ea.
    • Wire Chafing Dish w/Fuel $12 ea.
    • Cardboard Waste Bin $5 ea.

PLACE YOUR ORDER

To place your Catering Order – call or stop by your nearest Buehler’s location.

Or place your order online!