Mike Merritt

Mike Merritt

Director of Food Service Production

Our head chef, Mike, is passionate about creating delicious food! He and his team pride themselves in using the freshest ingredients in their made-from-scratch dishes…featuring locally sourced items whenever possible. Make your event extra special with chef-prepared, scrumptious food from Chef’s Kitchen Catering at Buehler’s.

Amy Kaylor

Amy Kaylor

Catering Sales & Marketing Manager

It’s so easy to plan an event when you have our Catering Specialists on your side! From choosing the perfect food, customizing our services to your needs and coordinating all the details, our goal is to make your life easy and your event outstanding!

What We Do Best

  • Weddings
  • Anniversaries
  • Baby & Bridal Showers
  • Birthday Parties
  • Corporate & Office Events
  • Funeral & Memorial Events
  • Graduations
  • Holiday Celebrations
  • Organizational Lunches & Events
  • Family Picnics

Ordering Information

How to Order

To place your Catering Order – call or stop by your nearest Buehler’s location.

Or place your order online!

Custom Orders

Don’t see what you’re looking for?  Our team of Chefs and Catering Specialists are here to help.  We can create custom menus and service options for any size group.  Give us a call today!

Notice

We appreciate at least a 48 hour notice on catering orders, however, we pride ourselves in our ability to accommodate last minute requests.  Give us a call to discuss what menu items can be made available in a pinch.

Pick Up

When coming to our store to pick up your order, please proceed to the Service Center where a smiling face will greet you.  We will bring your order right to you!

Delivery

Whether you are 5, 10, 15 or more miles from our store, we will deliver and set up your food and beverages so you can save time! local $15, Out of Town $25, and Long Distance $35.

Staff

we can provide staffing to make any occassion especially easy.  For $15 per staffer, per hour, service can include set up and tear down, buffet or plated meal service, bussing, non-alcoholic beverage service and much more.  Let us do the work so you don’t have to!

Hot or Cold

Your food can be prepared hot and ready to serve; or we can cook, then cool so it is ready to reheat at your convenience.

Pricing

Prices are subject to change.

  • Attention persons with food allergies to wheat, soy, eggs, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, fish and shellfish: Although the staff at Buehler’s takes precautions to safely handle and label ingredients and foods that contain potential allergens, cross-contamination may occur.  Highly sensitive individuals should discuss the risks of cross-contamination with their physician.

(V) = Vegetarian (additonal vegetarian items available upon request)

Breakfast

Complete your morning with our freshly brewed Scenic River coffee and a gallon of Smith’s orange juice.
Prices listed are for the Small (serves 8-12) size, view the description for Medium (serves 15-20), and Large (25-30) pricing.

  • Gourmet Muffins
    $15
    Big and bold these gourmet muffins are oversized and full of flavor! (Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Bagels
    $18
    These monster size bagels are made fresh every day!  Served with cream cheese. (Medium: $35, Large: $45)
  • Croissants
    $21
    Our flaky croissants are the best in town! Served with butter and jam. (Medium: $39, Large: $55)
  • Fruit & Yogurt Parfait
    $3
    Fresh fruit layered in creamy yogurt with crunchy granola on the side. (10 oz. cup)

  • Donuts
    $12
    From glazed to cake and apple fritters to cream sticks we make them fresh daily just for you. (Medium: $22, Large: $32)
  • Breakfast Pastry Sampler
    $18
    An assortment of bagels, gourmet muffins and croissants. (Medium: $35, Large: $45)
  • Petite Breakfast Pastry Sampler
    $14
    An assortment of mini bagels, mini muffins and mini croissants. (Medium: $28, Large: $42)
  • Fresh Fruit Salad
    $15
    A seasonal assortment of our ripest and sweetest melons, berries, pineapple and grapes. (Medium: $25, Large: $40)

Breakfast Buffet

Disposable Service Ware Included. Pricing is per person.

  • Classic Breakfast Buffet
    $10
    Fluffy scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, hash browns, fresh fruit and our house-made bagels with cream cheese.
  • French Toast Buffet
    $10
    Our famous French toast with maple syrup and butter deliciously paired with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon and fresh fruit.
  • Breakfast Casserole Buffet
    $10
    Made-from-scratch egg, sausage, cheese and hash brown casserole, fresh fruit and gourmet muffins.

BoxLunches

  • Express
    $7
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, kettle chips, dill pickle spear and gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Classic
    $8
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, chef prepared side, dill pickle spear and a gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Executive
    $9
    Your choice of a made-to-order sandwich or wrap, chef prepared side, kettle chips, dill pickle spear, bottled water and a chocolate chunk gourmet cookie.
  • Garden
    $9
    Your choice of freshly prepared garden salad, pita bread and a gourmet chocolate chunk cookie.
  • Junior
    $6
    Your choice of sandwich on fresh bread, served with kettle chips, dill pickle spear and a giant chocolate chunk cookie. Choose from ham & American, peanut butter & jelly or turkey & co-jack.
  • *Add bottled water or canned soda: $1.  Feeding a group? We can make your box into a buffet! Easy!
SANDWICH & WRAP CHOICES
  • Chicken Salad Croissant
  • Ham or Tuna Salad Croissant
  • Ham & Swiss on Pretzel Bun
  • Roast Beef Dijon on Pretzel Bun
  • All American Hoagie
  • Turkey Club Hoagie
  • Buffalo Chicken Hoagie
  • Cuban Hoagie
  • Italian Hoagie
  • Roast Beef Dijon Wrap
  • Turkey Club Wrap
  • Cobb Salad Wrap
  • Vegetarian Wrap
SALADS
  • Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar
  • Italian Bistro
  • Strawberry Salad with Grilled Chicken
  • Chef Salad
SIDES
  • Grandma’s Potato Salad
  • Cole Slaw
  • Broccoli Salad
  • Fresh Fruit Salad
  • Macaroni Salad

Party Trays

Prices listed are for the Small (serves 8-12) serving size. Check item descriptions for the Medium (serves 15-20) and Large (serves 25-30) prices.

Buehler's Fresh Foods sandwiches

SANDWICHES

  • Market Deli Meat Platter
    $35
    Our top-of-the-line meats (CAB roast beef, mild smokehouse ham, Buehler’s premium turkey breast and hard salami) freshly sliced for you! (Medium: $55, Large: $75)
  • Market Deli Combination Platter
    $39
    Our best quality meats (mild smokehouse ham, Certified Angus Beef roast beef and Buehler’s premium turkey breast) team up with colby, muenster and Swiss cheeses. (Medium: $59, Large: $79)
  • Hoagie Sandwich Tray
    $40
    A combination of our favorite Hoagies (Buffalo Chicken, Italian and Turkey Club) cut and ready to eat. (Medium: $66, Large: $99)
  • Deluxe Sandwich Topper Tray (V)
    $15
    Everything you need for the perfect sandwich. Lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle spears, banana peppers, mustard, mayo and ketchup.  (Medium: $25, Large: $35)
  • Slider Sandwich Tray
    $19
    Your own assortment of Market Deli meats or our homemade salad spreads piled high on our freshly baked slider buns.

    Choose up to 3: Oven Roasted Turkey, Mild Smokehouse Ham, Certified Angus Beef Roast Beef (add $5), Chunky Chicken Salad with Grapes, Tuna Salad, Ham Salad or Egg Salad (Medium: $38, Large: $57)

  • Triangle Sandwich Tray
    $19
    Choose from an assortment of our homemade salad spreads on fresh white, wheat and rye breads. Choose up to 3: Chunky Chicken Salad with Grapes, Tuna Salad, Ham Salad or Egg Salad. (Medium: $29, Large: $39)
  • Gourmet Tea Sandwich Tray
    $33
    Choose from our selection of gourmet combinations for a delicate mini sandwich display. Ham apple & brie, caprese or smoked salmon & cucumber. (Medium: $53, Large: $79)
  • Petite Croissant Sandwich Tray
    $21
    Your own assortment of Market Deli meats and spreads piled neatly on a miniature flaky croissant.

    Choose up to 3: Oven Roasted Turkey, Mild Smokehouse Ham, Certified Angus Beef Roast Beef (add $5), Chunky Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Ham Salad or Egg Salad Small. (Medium: $42, Large: $63)

  • Wrap Sandwich Tray
    $40
    A beautiful array of wrap sandwiches (Cobb, Turkey Club, and Roast Beef Dijon) cut in half and arranged on a tray. (Medium: $66, Large: $99)
Buehler's Fresh Foods party trays

CIRCLE SUBS

Substitute a pretzel bun for an additional $5.

  • Circle Sub Classic
    $45
    Buehler’s premium turkey breast, mild smokehouse ham and Colby cheese, garnished with lettuce tomato and pickle on a soft, Italian style bun with our famous sub sauce on the side. (serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Italian
    $52
    Mild smokehouse ham, hard salami, pepperoni, provolone, tomato, lettuce, banana peppers and Italian dressing on a soft, Italian style bun. (serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Deluxe
    $60
    Buehler’s premium turkey breast and CAB roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickle on a huge pretzel bun. Our famous sub sauce on the side. (serves 15-20)
  • Circle Sub Vegetable (V)
    $42
    Don’t forget about your veggie lovers! A soft Italian style bun piled high with spinach, red onion, black olives, carrots, bell peppers, tomato, pickles and creamy vegetable yogurt cheese. Served with a side of our famous dill dip. (serves 15-20)
Buehler's Fresh Foods vegetable trays

FRUITS & VEGGIES

  • Traditional Vegetable Tray (V)
    $22
    An assortment of fresh broccoli and cauliflower florets, baby carrots and celery sticks with creamy dill dip.  (Medium: $35, Large: $49)
  • Seasonal Fruit Tray (V)
    $21
    A mouthwatering array of our freshest melons, pineapple, grapes and berries. (Medium: $35, Large: $45)
  • Deluxe Relish Tray (V)
    $25
    Baby carrots, celery sticks, broccoli and cauliflower florets, radishes, sweet pickle mix, tomatoes, cucumbers and olives are all arranged around Buehler’s fresh dill dip. (Medium: $38, Large: $52)

MORE TO SHARE

  • Cocktail Shrimp
    $45
    Succulent tail-on jumbo shrimp (16/20 ct. size) served with our house-made cocktail sauce and fresh lemon wedges.  (Medium: $75, Large: $105)
  • Mediterranean Platter (V)
    $32
    The perfect mediterranean sampler complete with hummus, tabouli, banana peppers, stuffed grape leaves, olives, feta, cherry tomatoes and pita triangles. (Medium: $48, Large: $69)
  • Bruschetta Platter (V)
    $15
    Build your own! Sliced Italian baguette, our house-made tomato basil bruschetta and shaved parmesan cheese garnished with fresh basil. (Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Baked Brie (V)
    $20
    Pastry wrapped brie and fig served with our fresh Italian baguette.  (serves 15-20)
  • Meat and Cheese Snacker
    $28
    Hard salami, trail bologna, pepperoni, colby, provolone, and Swiss cheese, garnished with grapes. (Medium: $42, Large: $59)
  • Trail Bologna and Swiss
    $25
    An Ohio favorite! Troyer’s trail bologna and Holmes County Swiss cheese. Garnished with grapes. (Medium: $38, Large: $55)
  • Cheese Snacker
    $24
    An assortment of cut cheeses garnished with grapes. (Medium: $38, Large: $54)

Starters

Small (25 pcs), Medium (50 pcs), Large (100 pcs)

  • Spanikopita - V
    $28
    This bite-size savory Greek pastry is filled with spinach and cheese. (Medium: $54, Large: $99)
  • Vegetable Spring Rolls - V
    $33
    Fresh vegetables rolled into crispy bite size pieces and served with Teriyaki sauce. (Medium: $65, Large: $125)
  • Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts
    $40
    Hickory smoked bacon wrapped around a crunchy water chestnut. (Medium: $75, Large: $145)
  • Assorted Mini Quiche
    $32
    Our mini quiches are the perfect go-to appetizer while entertaining. (Medium: $62, Large: $120)

  • Mini Crab Cakes
    $32
    Bite-size crab cakes made from scratch and served with our roasted red pepper remoulade. (Medium: $60, Large: $115)
  • Mini Pinwheels
    $15
    Deliciously colorful, bite-size tortilla rollups. Available in roast beef-cheddar, jalapeno-bacon and turkey-cranberry (Medium: $30, Large: $60)
  • Breaded Cheese Ravioli (V)
    $23
    An Italian favorite, fried until golden brown and served with marinara. (Medium: $42, Large: $80)
  • Sauerkraut Balls
    $12
    Great for any party! Served with honey mustard dressing. (Medium: $24, Large: $48)
  • BBQ Cocktail Meatballs
    $12
    Juicy meatballs tossed in our own Smokehouse BBQ sauce.  (Medium: $24, Large: $48)
  • Shiitake Mushroom & Vegetable Potstickers (V)
    $22
    Steamed then pan seared and served with teriyaki sauce. (Medium: $42, Large: $78)
  • Pork Dumplings
    $22
    Tender pork dumplings steamed and served with teriyaki sauce.  (Medium: $42, Large: $78)
  • Vegetable Pizza (V)
    $24
    Flaky crust topped with creamy ranch spread, crispy vegetables and cheddar cheese, cut into squares.  (Medium: $45, Large: $85)
  • Fruit Pizza (V)
    $24
    A sugar cookie crest topped with sweetened cream cheese, our ripest fruit and cut into squares.  (Medium: $45, Large: $85)
  • Cream Cheese & Spinach Stuffed Mushrooms (V)
    $22
    Button mushrooms filled with cream cheese and spinach, topped with panko.  (Medium: $40, Large: $78)
  • Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
    $18
    Seasoned sausage stuffed button mushrooms. (Medium: $34, Large: $68)
  • Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
    $24
    Juicy crab-filled button mushrooms.  (Medium: $45, Large: $89)
  • Antipasto Skewers
    $30
    Market Deli salami, provolone cheese, tortellini and cherry tomatoes, marinated in a house-made vinaigrette.  (Medium: $60, Large: $110)
  • Fresh Fruit Skewers (V)
    $25
    Fresh fruit on a 4-inch skewer. (Medium: $48, Large: $95)
  • Caprese Skewers (V)
    $38
    Fresh mozzarella, basil and tomato. Drizzled with balsamic reduction. (Medium: $74, Large: $148)
  • Teriyaki Chicken & Pineapple Skewers
    $40
    Juicy chicken chunks and fresh pineapple baked with our homemade teriyaki sauce.  (Medium: $75, Large: $150)
  • Deviled Eggs (V)
    $14
     (Medium: $25, Large: $48)
  • Potato Skins
    $14
    Crispy potato skins topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, scallions and a side of sour cream.  (Medium: $28, Large: $56)
Buehler's Fresh Foods catering

SALADS GARDEN FRESH

Small: 8-12, Medium: 15-20, Large: 25-30

  • Caesar (V)
    $18
    Crispy Romaine lettuce topped with fresh mushrooms, red onion, garlic and herb croutons, and a sprinkle of parmesan cheese. Served with our classic creamy Caesar dressing on the side. (Medium: $25, Large: $44)

    Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
    (Small: $32, Medium: $44, Large: $74)

  • Chefs Salad
    $21
    Mixed greens topped with smokehouse ham, oven roasted turkey, mushrooms, hard-boiled egg, cucumber, tomato, bacon, shredded Swiss cheese and cheese and garlic croutons. (Medium: $28, Large: $48)
  • Cobb Salad
    $26
    Mixed greens topped with hard-boiled eggs, shredded cheeses, crispy bacon, red onion, avocado and cherry tomatoes. (Medium: $38, Large: $68)
  • Greek Salad (V)
    $21
    Crispy mixed greens loaded with feta cheese, kalamata olives, roasted red peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion and pita bread. Served with Greek feta cheese dressing. (Medium: $31, Large: $56)

    Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken
    Small $32, Medium $48, Large $79

  • Garden Salad (V)
    $16
    Crisp lettuce, cherry tomatoes, red onion, and green peppers make this a refreshing salad.  (Medium: $23, Large: $39)

    Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
    Small $29, Medium $40, Large $68

  • Harvest Salad
    $20
    Crisp gala apples, sugared pecans, and sweet craisins are served over mixed greens and topped with crumbled bleu cheese and sweet and sour raspberry dressing. (Medium: $28, Large: $48)
  • Strawberry Salad (V)
    $22
    Ruby red strawberries and creamy crumbled bleu cheese atop mixed greens, sugared pecans and sweet and sour raspberry dressing. (Medium: $28, Large: $48)

    Strawberry Salad with Grilled Chicken
    Small: $32, Medium: $45, Large: $75

  • Italian Bistro Salad
    $18
    Crispy romaine lettuce is topped with a hearty combination of hot banana peppers, black olives, tomato, red onion, pepperoni, and shredded parmesan then served with crunchy croutons and lite Italian dressing. (Medium: $24, Large: $42)
Buehler's Fresh Foods Catering Potato Salad

CHEF PREPARED

Small: 8-12, Medium: 15-20, Large: 25-30

  • Potato Salad (V)
    $12
    Traditional potato salad just like grandma used to make. (Medium: $20, Large: $30)
  • Macaroni Salad (V)
    $12
    Elbow macaroni, onions, pickle relish and fresh celery in our own creamy sauce. (Medium: $20, Large: $30)
  • Italian Bowtie Pasta
    $20
    Tender bowtie pasta with olives, banana peppers, pepperoni and parmesan tossed in our own Italian style vinaigrette. (Medium: $34, Large: $55)
  • Garden Ranch Pasta Salad (V)
    $18
    Corkscrew pasta, carrots, zucchini, celery, peas, corn, onions, and red peppers in a ranch style dressing. (Medium: 30, Large: $45)
  • Kale Salad (V)
    $22
    Chopped kale, cherry tomatoes, northern beans, sunflower and sesame seeds tossed in a refreshing lemon vinaigrette dressing. (Medium: $35, Large: $54)
  • Antipasto Salad
    $21
    A variety of Italian meats and cheeses, marinated in our own dressing with olives and banana peppers. (Medium: $35, Large: $56)
  • Broccoli Salad
    $21
    Broccoli, sweet raisins and crumbled bacon tossed in our signature creamy dressing. (Medium: $35, Large: $54)
  • Cole Slaw (V)
    $12
    Classic creamy coleslaw. (Medium: $20, Large: $30)
  • Fresh Fruit Salad (V)
    $15
    A seasonal assortment of our ripest and sweetest melons, berries, pineapple and grapes. (Medium: $25, Large: $40)
  • Southwest Quinoa (V)
    $21
    A delicious mix of quinoa, diced Spanish onions, black beans and cilantro in a light lime dressing. (Medium: $35, Large: $54)

SIDES

Half (serves 12), Full (serves 24)

  • Cheesy Potato Casserole
    $20
    Thinly shredded potatoes with sour cream and a blend of savory cheeses. Covered with a corn-flake topping and baked until golden brown. (Full: $38)
  • Honey Glazed Green Beans
    $20
    Fresh green beans blended with honey, dried cranberries, and sugared pecans. A great addition to any fall meal. (Full: $38)
  • Garlic Green Beans
    $20
    Green beans sautéed in a butter garlic sauce. (Full: $38)
  • Green Bean Casserole
    $12
    Green beans mixed with cream of mushroom soup and topped with fried onions and then baked until bubbly. (Full: $20)
Buehler's Catering Mashed Potatoes
  • Grilled Marinated Asparagus
    $22
    Fresh asparagus, bathed in our signature marinade and grilled on an open flame to give it a smoky char. (Full: $40)
  • Honey Glazed Carrots
    $15
    Delicate baby carrots roasted in a light honey sauce. (Full: $25)
  • Smoked Gouda Redskin Potatoes
    $15
    Boring potatoes move over! Sweet red potatoes, caramelized onions and creamy smoked gouda cheese make these a crowd pleaser. (Full: $25)
  • Au Gratin or Scalloped Potatoes
    $18
     (Full: $35)
  • Homemade Mac & Cheese
    $24
    Tender shells mixed with a creamy blend of cheeses.  (Full: $45)
  • Twice Baked Potatoes
    $23
    A baked potato stuffed with potato, cheddar cheese, bacon, sour cream, and scallions.  (Full: $45)
  • Grilled Marinated Veggies
    $22
    Mixed vegetables marinated in our signature marinade and grilled over an open flame.  (Full: $40)
  • Bread Dressing
    $18
    Buehler’s spin on a classic dish. Made from scratch. Only fresh ingredients used here! (Full: $35)
  • Mashed Potatoes
    $13
    (Full: $25)
  • Whipped Sweet Potatoes
    $17
    Sweet potatoes whipped with cream and sugar and topped with brown sugar and crushed walnuts. (Full: $32)
  • Parsley Noodles
    $18
    Tender egg noodles mixed with spices and parsley.  (Full: $35)
  • Smokehouse Beans
    $18
    A blend of great northern & kidney beans simmered in our signature Smokehouse bbq sauce and finished in the smoker. (Full: $35)
  • Oven Roasted Rosemary Poatatoes
    $18
    Yukon gold potatoes, olive oil and fresh rosemary make these a crowd pleaser! (Full: $35)

HOMEMADE SOUP

Cup (serves 1) $3.49, Quart (serves 4) $7.99, Gallon (serves 16) $39

  • Mushroom Bisque
    A medley of fresh mushrooms with a pinch of rosemary, thyme and sage blended into a creamy bisque.
  • Chicken Noodle Soup
    Home-style white meat chicken, thin noodles and carrots simmered in a delicate broth.
  • Loaded Potato Soup
    Hearty potatoes, bacon, scallions and cheddar cheese makes this soup delicious and filling.
  • Tomato Basil Bisque
    Fresh tomatoes and flat leaf basil.

Freshly Baked Italian Bread

___________

Add a loaf to your order for only $4

  • Bean & Chipotle (V)
    Black beans, corn, potatoes and peppers simmered in a spicy chipotle tomato sauce for a hearty vegan soup all can enjoy.
  • Chili
    Beef and bean chili simmered in a classic tomato sauce with just the right kick.
  • Broccoli Noodle (V)
    Thin noodles, fresh broccoli and lots of cheese makes this creamy soup one of a kind.

ENTREES

Half (serves 12), Full (serves 24)

Buehler's catering salmon
  • Meat Lasagna
    $45
    Layers of lasagna noodles, hearty meat sauce and rich ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. (Full: $85)
  • Vegetable Lasagna (V)
    $45
    Layered noodles, fresh vegetables and cheeses in a rich cream sauce. (Full: $85)
  • Rotini with Meat Sauce
    $29
    A hearty dish perfect for all ages. (Full: $55)
  • Penne Pasta Primavera
    $29
    Fresh vegetables and creamy garlic alfredo sauce over penne pasta. (Full: $55)
  • Oven Roasted Pork Tenderloin
    $45
    Succulent tenderloin and sautéed onions in an Asian inspired marinade. (Full: $89)
  • Ham Loaf or Meat Loaf
    $45
    Just like Grandma Buehler used to make.  (Full: $85)
  • Oven Roasted Turkey Breast
    $45
    Juicy turkey breast seasoned and oven roasted to golden perfection. (Full: $85)
  • Stuffed Chicken Breasts
    $42
    A juicy Gerber chicken breast stuffed with our classic bread dressing and topped with gravy.  (Full: $80)
  • Chicken Parmesan
    $42
    A breaded chicken breast topped with our zesty marinara and melted provolone cheese.  (Full: $80)
  • Grilled Lemon Chicken
    $35
    A Gerber chicken breast marinated in fresh-squeezed lemon juice.  (Full: $70)
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu
    $42
    A fresh chicken breast rolled with ham and Swiss cheese, smothered in dijon mustard and seasoned bread crumbs. (Full: $80)
  • Asiago Chicken
    $49
    A juicy chicken cutlet lightly breaded and pan fried. Encrusted with asiago cheese and melted until bubbly and golden. (Full: $95)
  • Buffalo Chicken Breast
    $44
    A crispy chicken cutlet topped with melted blue cheese and drizzled with our special buffalo sauce. (Full: $85)
  • Swiss Steak
    $35
    A hearty steak tenderized and slow cooked in our own beef gravy.  (Full: $65)
  • Prime Rib
    $125
    Certified Angus Beef prime rib roast served with au jus.  (Full: $235)
  • Stuffed Peppers
    $65
    A light and fluffy blend of ground beef, pork, and rice stuffed into a fire roasted bell pepper. Simmered in a tomato basil sauce.  (Full: $120)
  • Grilled Salmon
    $72
    Lightly seasoned salmon filet grilled to perfection.  (Full: $140)
  • Baked Cod
    $45
    A fresh cod filet rolled in a combination of corn flakes and cracker crumbs. Baked until golden brown and flaky. (Full: $88)
  • Italian Sausage with Peppers & Onions
    $35
    Juicy, sweet Italian sausage, with sautéed fresh bell pepper, white onions, and garlic. (Full: $65)

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

CHICKEN

Add your favorite dipping sauce for only $4 lb.
Choose from Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard or BBQ Sauce

  • Fried Chicken
    $28.99
    Our authentic crispy fried chicken, great for your next party or family get together! (Small – 24 pc: $28.99, Medium – 48 pc: $55.99, Large – 96 pc: $99.99)
  • JoJos (V)
    $8
    Jumbo potato wedges, breaded & deep fried.  (Small – 24 pcs: $8, Large – 48 pcs: $12)
  • Chicken Tenders
    $39
    Freshly battered and deep fried golden brown. (Half – serves 12: $39, Full – serves 24: $75)
  • Boneless Wings
    $20
    Crispy, boneless chicken wings tossed in your favorite sauce. Choose 1: Sweet BBQ, Teriyaki, Kickin’ Bourbon or Dry.  (Small – 25 piece: $20, Medium – 50 piece: $39, Large – 100 piece:$78)
  • Market Deli Wings
    $16
    Our juicy market deli chicken wings are perfect for a game day, family gathering or just because.  Choose 1: Sweet BBQ, Teriyaki, Kickin’ Bourbon or Dry.  (Small – serves 8-12: $16, Medium – serves 15-20: $31, Large – serves 25-30: $60)
Buehler's catering salmon

DINNER BUFFET

Choose from the ENTREES and SIDES selections in this menu.
Plastic disposable table ware included. (20 person minimum)

$10 upcharge for Prime Rib or Salmon

  • House
    $15
    1 entrée and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)
  • Signature
    $18
    2 entrées and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)
  • Grand
    $21
    3 entrées and 2 side options, tossed salad and dinner rolls with butter. (per person)

SMOKEHOUSE BBQ

Smokehouse BBQ Buffet

10 Person Minimum • Disposable Service Ware Included • Available Year Round at Select Locations

Buehler's Smokehouse BBQ ribs
  • BBQ Buffet Meat Selections
    • Pulled Pork
    • Chopped or Sliced Brisket
    • Smoked Sausage
    • Pulled Chicken
    • 1/2 Smoked Chicken ($2 upcharge)
  • BBQ Buffet Side Selections
    • Smoked Mac & Cheese
    • Smokehouse Beans
    • Smoked Baked Potato
    • Coleslaw
    • Collard Greens
    • Potato Salad
    • Tossed Salad
  • The Little Squealer
    $9.99
    One meat, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce. (per person)
  • The Fine Swine
    $11.99
    Our most popular! Two meats, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce.  (per person)
  • Hog Heaven
    $13.99
    Three meats, 2 sides, buns & BBQ sauce. (per person)
  • Rib Buffet
    $15.99
    Ribs plus one meat option, 2 sides, buns, & BBQ sauce. (per person)

Smokehouse BBQ Entrees and Sides

  • Smokehouse Pulled Pork
    $39
    Hand-pulled pork shoulder smoked until tender. Served with Smokehouse bbq sauce on the side.  (Half – serves 12: $39, Whole – serves 24: $75)
  • Smokehouse Beef Brisket
    $99
    CAB beef brisket, rubbed with our secret recipe of dry spices and smoked for hours. (Half – serves 12: $99, Whole – serves 24: $198)
  • Smokehouse Ribs
    $60
    Dry rubbed St. Louis style ribs topped with BBQ sauce. (Half – serves 12: $60, Full: $115)
  • Smokehouse Salmon
    $99
    Tender salmon smoked to perfection in our hickory wood smoker. (Half – serves $12: 99, Full: $198)
  • Smokehouse Sausage
    $45
    Locally made and smoked in-house in a variety of flavors.  (Half – serves 12: $45, Full: $85)

  • Smokehouse Pulled Chicken
    $39
    A local favorite! Gerber chickens are seasoned with our famous dry rub and smoked to perfection over hickory wood. (Half – serves 12: $39, Whole – serves 24: $75)
  • Smokehouse Mac and Cheese (V)
    $30
    Our traditional creamy, homemade mac & cheese finished in smoker for a subtle hint of hickory. (Half – serves 12: $30, Whole – serves 24: $55)
  • Smokehouse Beans (V)
    $18
    A blend of great northern & kidney beans simmered in our signature Smokehouse bbq sauce..  (Half – serves 12: $18, Whole – serves 24: $35)

Chef Attended Smoker

___________

We can bring it to your party!  $99 for 3 hours.

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

SUSHI

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Large Party Platters

  • Honolulu Queen
    $21
    • 8 pcs. California roll
    • 8 pcs. veggie roll
    • 24 pcs. hissho healthy
    • 8 pcs. Philadelphia roll
  • Shikoku Crystals
    $35
    • 8 pcs. California roll
    • 8 pcs. biggie roll
    • 8 pcs. pollo picante
    • 8 pcs. mango tango
    • 4 pcs. spicy inari
    • 6 nigiri
  • Yokohama Dynasty
    $38
    • 8 pcs. Queen City roll
    • 8 pcs. Outer Banks roll
    • 8 pcs. ninja roll
    • 8 pcs. grand finale
    • 6 nigiri
  • Kyoto Majesty
    $48
    • 8 pcs. California roll
    • 8 pcs. Queen City roll
    • 8 pc. eel roll
    • 8 pc. wasabi crunch
    • 8 pc. sriracha party
    • 8 pcs. grand finale
    • 6 nigiri

Medium Party Platters

  • Hamanasu
    $16
    • 4 pcs. garden spring roll
    • 4 pcs. grilled chicken spring roll
    • 4 pcs. ocean spring roll
    • 8 pcs. spring roll
  • Sazanka
    $17
    • 8 pcs. sriracha party
    • 8 pcs. Philadelphia roll
    • 4 pcs. nigiri
  • Ikishia
    $18
    • 8 pcs. biggie roll
    • 8 pcs. veggie roll
    • 8 pcs. California roll
  • Sakura
    $19
    • 8 pcs. wasabi crunch
    • 8 pcs. sushicado roll
    • 4 pcs. spicy inari
  • 48 Hour Advanced Notice Required
    Not available at all locations

EXTRAS

DIPS & SPREADS

  • Buehler’s Dill Dip
    $5/lb
  • Fruit Yogurt Dip
    $5/lb
  • Buffalo Chicken Dip
    $6/lb
  • Spinach Dip
    $6/lb
  • Fresh Salsa
    $6/lb
  • Pimento Cheese Spread
    $6/lb
  • Bruschetta
    $7/lb
  • Hummus
    $7/lb
  • Ham or Tuna Salad
    $7/lb
  • Chicken Salad
    $8/lb
  • Egg Salad
    $5/lb

CHIPS & BREADS

  • Sliced Baguette
    $5 ea.
  • Sliced Italian Bread
    $4
    1 loaf
  • Garlic Bread
    $4
    1 loaf
  • Buehler’s Buns
    $2
    8 pack
  • Assorted Crackers
    $6
    12 oz. box
  • Pita Triangles
    $5
    24 piece box
  • Lays Potato Chips
    $4
    8 oz. bag
  • Tortilla Chips
    $4
    10 oz. box
  • Pita Chips
    $4
    8 oz. box

BAKERY SWEETS

Small (serves 8-12), Medium (serves 15-20), Large (serves 25-30)

  • Buehler’s Cookie Tray
    $10
    Chocolate chip, peanut butter, white chocolate macadamia nut or oatmeal raisin.  (Medium: $18, Large: $25)
  • Our House Cookie Tray
    $8
    Made from scratch dough, iced with our homemade buttercream icing and seasonally decorated. (Medium: $15, Large: $20)
  • Gourmet Cookie Tray
    $13
    Freshly baked jumbo cookies that come in a wide variety of flavors including chunky chocolate chip, almond joy, caramel pecan, s’more, cranapple or peanut butter. (Medium: $25, Large: $36)
  • Buehler’s Brownie Tray
    $12
    Buehler’s favorite frosted fudge brownie with or without nuts. (Medium: $22, Large: $32)
Buehler's bakery catering cookies and bars
  • Forbidden Brownie Tray
    $20
    Rich and gooey layered brownies. Choose from original, salted caramel, peanut butter and not-a-nutter. (Medium: $38, Large: $54)
  • Cupcake Tray
    $14
    Perfect for birthdays, holidays or any occasion. We bake our cupcakes fresh and frost with buttercream icing. Available in white and chocolate.  (Medium: $26, Large: $36)
  • Sweets Sampler Tray
    $15
    A variety of cookies, brownies, clothespin cookies and delicious chocolate fudge. (Medium: $30, Large: $45)
  • Also available:  PIES, TORTES & MORE!  Call or visit your store to order. 

PETITE DESSERT TRAY

Assortment of mini cheese cakes, gourmet brownies, pecan tarts and lemon bars.
(Small – serves 8-12: $26, Medium – serves 15-20: $40, Large – serves 25-30: $60)

AVAILABLE BY THE DOZEN

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberries – $18 doz.
  • Pecan Tarts – $12 doz.
  • Petite Lemon Bars – $8 doz.
  • Petite Gourmet Brownies – $12
  • Petite Cupcakes – $5 doz.
  • Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies – $5 doz.
  • Clothespin Cookies – $5 doz.
  • Assorted Petite Cheesecakes – $16 doz.

CUSTOM CAKES

Let us customize a delicious, one-of-a-kind homemade cake for your special occasion.

Choose from our premium homemade buttercream icings, rolled fondant and Marzipan enrobed cakes, to our fresh and seasonal fruit fillings and specialty cake flavors like European sponge. Let us help you create something unique!

RECEIVE A FREE CONSULTATION

with one of our talented decorators!

We do it all!

  • BIRTHDAYS
  • ANNIVERSARIES
  • GRADUATIONS
  • BRIDAL & BABY SHOWERS
  • WEDDINGS
  • HOLIDAY/SEASONAL
  • AND MORE!

BEVERAGES

All beverages include cups. Ready to serve. Quantity Recommendations: 1 gallon: serves 16, 2 liter soda: serves 8

  • Scenic River Coffee
    $12
    Our favorite brand of coffee! Available in Regular or Decaf. Includes sugar, sugar substitutes, creamer, and stir sticks. (Per gallon)
  • Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
    $9
    Freshly brewed just for you!  Includes sugar and sugar substitutes.  (Per gallon)
  • Flavored Iced Tea
    $9
    Choose your favorite flavor. Includes sugar packets. (Per gallon)
  • Buehler’s Lemonade
    $7
    Our refreshing house brand lemonade. (Per gallon)
  • Smith’s Orange Juice
    $10
    Our favorite brand of refreshing orange juice. (Per gallon)
  • Smith’s Punch
    $6
    Choose from a variety of flavors. (Per gallon)

  • Bottled Water
    $1 per bottle
    Buehler’s won 100% Natural Spring Water.
  • Canned Soda
    $1 per can
    Your choice of refreshing Coca Cola or Pepsi brand products.
  • 2 Liter Soda
    $4 per btl.
    Your choice of refreshing Coca Cola or Pepsi brand products.

WINE

A few of our favorites.

  • Eroica Riesling
    From Washington. Sweet lime and peach aromas with subtle mineral notes. Pairs well with grilled pork, poultry, seafood or Asian dishes.
  • Butter Chardonnay
    From California. Tropical fruit and buttery palate with a creamy texture and lots of toasty vanilla oak spice. Pairs with chicken, turkey, pork or fish.
  • Ghost Pines Cabernet Sauvignon
    From California. Dark berry fruit blends in with toasted vanilla flavors and firm tannins. Pairs with beef, lamb or pasta.
  • Kendall Jackson Chardonnay
    From California. Tropical flavors such as pineapple, mango and papaya with citrus notes: a hint of toasted oak rounds out the finish. Pairs well with chicken, turkey, pork or fish.
  • Concannon Conservancy Cabernet Sauvignon
    From California.. A full bodied wine, rich with black cherry and vanilla oak flavors. Pairs with beef, lamb or pasta.

  • Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling
    From Washington. Apricot, grapefruit and peach flavors – light bodied. Pairs well with seafood, chicken or spicy cuisine.
  • Meiomi Pinot Noir
    From California. Rich yet medium-weight, offering an exciting interplay of berry, oak, earth and spice notes, with subtle edges to the blueberry, raspberry, mocha and fresh-turned earth flavors. Pairs well with lamb, veal, salmon and light pasta dishes.
  • Apothic Red
    From California. Intense fruit aromas of strawberry and black cherries with just a hint of spice and chocolate; bold, ripe flavors with a long, sleek finish. Pairs well with steak, spicy food or pasta.
  • Nobilo Sauvignon Blanc
    From New Zealand. Intense aromas of pineapple, passion fruit and guava and pineapple notes. The wine has an excellent presence and mouthfeel, with balanced acidity and a generous finish. Pairs with seafood, chicken or spicy cuisine.
Wine with catering

BEER

  • Great Lakes Beer
    Choose from:

    • Burning River Pale Ale
    • Commodore Perry IPA
    • Dortmunder Gold Lager
    • Elliot Ness Amber Lager
    • Edmund Fitzgerald Porter
  • Samuel Adams Beer
    Choose from Boston Lager or Rebel IPA
  • Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

FLORAL

Let our talented floral designers customize one-of-a-kind, beautiful arrangements for your special occasion.

  • We do it all!
    • Weddings
    • Funerals
    • Anniversaries
    • Bridal & Baby Showers
    • Birthdays
    • Holiday/Seasonal and more!

    Schedule your free consultation today!

GIFTS

For all occasions! Stop in and browse our large selection of cards and gifts:

  • Stop in and browse our large selection of cards and gifts:
    • Mylar & Latex Balloons
    • Yankee Candles
    • Willow Tree
    • Home Decor
    • Birthdays
    • Seasonal Wreaths
    • Blooming & Foliage Plants
    • American Greetings Cards
    • Ty Plush
    • Vases & Pottery
    • and more!

PARTY SUPPLIES

  • Tableware
    Make clean-up a breeze with these durable options.

    • Cutlery Roll  50¢ ea.
      (heavy napkin, knife, fork & spoon)
    • Heavy Duty Ovation Paper Plates/Bowls $1 per person
    • Clear Plastic Plates/Bowls $2 per person
  • Serving Utensils
    Heavy duty, plastic disposable.

    • Tongs (6 or 10 inch) $1 ea.
    • Serving Spoon $1 ea.
    • Ladle (1 or 4 oz.) $1 ea.
    • Pie Server  $1 ea.
    • Spatula $1 ea.
  • Rentals
    Borrow our top of the line equipment.

    • Beverage Dispenser (Hot or Cold) $5 ea.
    • Chafing Dish w/Fuel $15 ea.
    • Chest Cooler $5 ea.
    • Hot Box $5 ea.
  • Keepers
    Don’t forget these convenient party savers.

    • Plastic Table Cover $3 ea.
    • Wire Chafing Dish w/Fuel $12 ea.
    • Cardboard Waste Bin $5 ea.

PLACE YOUR ORDER

To place your Catering Order – call or stop by your nearest Buehler’s location.

Or place your order online!